Comments - The Cardamom Game - by Will Manidis - Minutes

Source: original

Minutes

SubscribeSign in

The Cardamom Game

The Cardamom Game Read →

17 Comments

Top first

surya yalamanchili

Apr 27

yo. you have been dropping some bangers 🙏🏾🫡 🤝

Reply

Persnickety Poore

Apr 28

This sounds like fiction and the author reminds me of Italo Calvino‘s writing. Absolutely beautiful!

Reply

QC

May 2

most of this is really lovely but is it just me or does it start to get weirdly repetitive around "Perhaps the Bedouin remembered no spirit at all" in a way that feels either like a weird editing mistake or like an LLM wrote the rest of it? maybe this was intentional?

Reply

Tim O'Reilly

Apr 27Edited

I wonder if this is a scrying that lets us see our own future. Neil Postman Amusing Ourselves to Death and EM Forster The Machine Stops. A remarkable piece of largely unsung history.

Reply (1)

Hana Kabele Gala

Apr 27

I had the same thought, Postman's book in particular came to mind.

Reply

BingBong

Apr 27

I’m such a sucker for this kind of piece. Wonderful job.

Reply

Alexa Davis

May 2

I loved this. Great writing!

Reply

Anna Gát

May 1

♥️

Reply

Thomas

May 1

Great verisimilitude.

Reply

the Wizard Friston

Apr 30

RIP Borges

Reply

mariana feistauer

Apr 28

wonderful piece. we need more of this kind of reading.

Reply

Hana Kabele Gala

Apr 27

What a stunning piece, again. The game seems to be communicating Thomas Sowell's quote: 'There are no solutions, only tradeoffs.'

More importantly, it highlights again that men will amuse themselves to death if not grounded (or rather elevated?) by a higher order. A life without transcendence leads to an intricate but ultimately dead-end state.

Also, what a fascinating example of a cognitive ratchet: expanding the mind to the next level systems thinking.

Reply

J9999

Apr 27

Is this real? Did this really happen? I very much enjoyed it

Reply (2)

Rochan

Apr 27

Really trying to find a record that has all the rules so I can play with a friend

Reply (1)

J9999

Apr 27

Be careful - apparently it’s quite a dangerous game! Or a parable…

Reply

Mona Alsubaei

Apr 27

I don't think so! But the game mentioned in the story might be Mancala from Kitāb al-Aghānī (which he references here).

This is a fascinating and strange thing! I enjoyed it so much. I'd love to hear more about how you chose the images, wrote some of the quotes, and decided which scholars to attribute them to.

Reply

Treeamigo

Apr 27

Beautiful

Reply